Steve you should be a very happy man. That was great! All it takes is a little time and patience. Alexmos can have equal performance to Movi in the air if you put in the necessary work tuning which in my own opinion is no different than the time needed to setup a Movi. As for horizon roll during fast pans, I've seen Movi do this as well. Slow down your pans and you won't have that issue besides you won't ever need to pan that fast while onset filming. What changes have you made from the last video?
Thanks, man! I agree. I’ve seen some pretty questionable footage in some MōVI clips, even in handheld work. And I’ve seen precious little decent aerial work. I think the reason for the scarcity of MōVI MR stuff is there just aren’t that many out there, and it’s still really hard to get a good, reliable, stable platform up there. Those of us who have been working a lot on our copters have a leg up. There’s no “plug-and-play”, even if you spend a boatload of money. Backed off on my gains a bit as per Fabian’s instructions (found this on the forum http://bit.ly/18Ofm2c ...it’s great).Also, I got the roll (pitch) working from my transmitter (just had to add a ground wire...duh) so now I can actually aim my camera. And today I’m going out with the FPV working again, so I’m hoping to get some footage of something other than the parking lot and my own head.
Thanks Bill! A few things here... I talked to Grayson at Brushlessgimbals.com and he said the 8108 is the same motor as the gb-85 except that it has a dust cover. I have the exact 8017 and pulley pan axis that you suggested to another someone else from aliexpress. I am getting a stair stepping effect when I pan left or right. I have heard this is a problem with belt reduction. What is the remedy for that? I multiplied the 28 poles times 4 which is the number of times the motor spins for 1 rotation of the main hub. I dropped my power to 150 and my PIDs to 9 0.2 17 with gyro high sensitivity on. What are your thoughts? Thanks in advance!
Sam I don't know what Grayson told you but if you have the GB85-1 on hand spin it and see how many steps you get. There's no info for the wire size, resistance or magnet count anywhere that I looked. Even Sharon at T-motor could not tell me, so I don't know how he can confirm this. I have 3 GB85's, 3 8108's, 38017's, 3 GB100-10 and 3 PM60 on hand. Since I can see the magnets on the 8108 and 8017 I can count them But on the GB85, GB100 and PM60 they are sealed so I had to spin them slowly and count the steps. On the GB85 I count almost 100 plus count on the GB100 is the same as the 8108 and on the PM 60 is smooth as silk I don't know how many poles it has. Those were my findings. Try those PID's on the pan. Power 170 P=26 I=0.22 D=23 Bill
So here’s some actual flying footage, rather than flying in circles around my own head. This was all filmed at pretty high altitude (6000-9000 feet) with some pretty windy conditions. I did use some Warp Stabilizer, as things got a little hairy in some places. But the gimbal’s doing great. Thanks again to everybody here...can’t wait to do some more!
Thanks, Dave. Next on the agenda is to try and get a 3rd axis up and running. However, I am concerned I’m running out of GVW for my motors. In the X8 config I’ve lost quite a bit of horsepower, and the QC3328 motors may not be up to the task. So if I go to the 3rd axis (and landing gear, etc) I may have to go back to the flat 8. Or, it may be time for the heavy lifter. Here’s what my GPX header looks like. As you can see, I’m pushing some serious power. Of course, this was at 8000’ ASL, so maybe I should hold out hope that back at sea level in Half Moon Bay I’ll be better off. I also have to mess with the mixer settings a bit. My bottom motors 5-8 (which are set to 71) can be backed off a little, I think. MK Version: FC HW:2.2 SW:2.02a + NC HW:2.0 SW:2.02aFlight date: 12/27/2013 10:11:08 AMFlight time: 10:11:08 AM - 10:17:15 AM (367 secs, 00:06:07)Batt. time : 365 secs, 00:06:05Elevation(GPS) : 0.172 20.94 40.81 m (min/avg/max)Altitude(Barom.): -2.4 19.4 40.55 mVertical speed : -2.74 -0.09 2.82 m/sMax speed : 39.3 km/hMax target dist.: 0 mSats : 10 9 11Voltage : min. 13.7, max. 15.4 VCurrent : 0.5 87 123.8 AWattage : 7 1264 1696.06 WCapacity: 8969 mAhMotor1: 0.3 8.6 14.5 A Temp: 14 30 53 °CMotor2: 0.0 9.4 14.0 A Temp: 14 32 49 °CMotor3: 0.0 10.2 19.4 A Temp: 14 37 51 °CMotor4: 0.0 11.0 15.8 A Temp: 20 44 52 °CMotor5: 0.0 11.6 20.1 A Temp: 15 46 57 °CMotor6: 0.0 13.3 22.0 A Temp: 13 48 61 °CMotor7: 0.1 10.0 17.0 A Temp: 11 36 56 °CMotor8: 0.5 11.2 17.5 A Temp: 16 38 54 °CMagnet Field: 89 97 111 % (ok)Magnet Inclination: 48 57 74 deg
Hi Kari Thanks for your tips. They are greatly appreciated. Where did you get the aluminium booms in the right diameter? Abut the flight: It was a quick test flight and I think I was not above those kids. Maybe I was then. It definitely is against my safety principles to fly above kids or people in general. Must be more careful next time. @ Bill: Do you think Famous Hobby will send the pan reduction thingy you linked without the motor as I already have it. I wrote them but not reply at least yet.
@Tuukka Yes they will, just write an email to Harry or Una and he will send it to you. I did the same I don't need the motor as I have plenty. Bill PS. you better hurry as a Chinese holiday is coming up
Hi Bill, Have you tried the PM60 yet. I know they say it is a PMSM and should be smoother but I can't find much info from reliable sources that have actually used the PM60 or PM57. Which controller are you using for the PM60?
@Milo I am waiting for the controller. The PM 57 and 60 have 4 wires instead of three. I need the new controller with the extra ground. They look like the ones the MoVi uses. The mounting holes are all 2.5mm not three. I have to retap them or get some 2.5mm screws. @Ozkan No not yet. They are too big for the cages that I have I have to figure out how to mount them. Bill
Thank Bill, Do you have any instructions on what to do with the fourth wire and its function? I am confused because looking at the pictures and drawings it looks like the PM60 has 4 wires and the PM57 has three wires. I know the ranger gimbal is shipping with the PM57 but I don't know if there is an extra wire addded for "mtr ground" or if the PM57 only needs three wires. I have tried asking the company but never get a useful answer.
On the new 3axis controller there's a GND pad on the board to attach the GND wire. Look at the photo. As for the 57 I don't know. I have to investigate. Bill
@Sam Did you manage to improve the pan with the new settings? I am about to buy the Aliexpress pulley, but maybe not if it does not work. Presently I have the direct drive pan axis cage for 8017 from brushlessgimbals.com